Scoresheet Saturday: New Belgium Citradelic

So, I thought it would it would be fun to add a weekly blog post called Scoresheet Saturday. The goal of these posts is to force us to spend more time studying for the BJCP proficiency exam by regularly writing score sheets and evaluating beers. My goal is to publish one or more score sheets every Saturday. I am hoping my other SFF cohorts join me on occasion in writing score sheets. These posts will also give us an opportunity to receive feedback from each other and other experienced judges. All three of us have scored high enough on the tasting exam to attempt taking the written proficiency exam. However, since we have taken our tasting exams, the BJCP has switched to the 2015 guidelines, so things have changed a bit in terms of judging. To be consistent with what we would experience during an exam or a judging session, we’ll keep to a 20 minute evaluation and writing period. I hope these posts will help you and us prepare for future BJCP exams.

25239356240_47577a21d2_bJudge: Ron Unz
BJCP ID: F0711
Rank: Certified
Beer Name: New Belgium Citradelic
Category: 21A – American IPA
Special Ingredients: None
Bottle Inspection: Ok.
Comments: None

Aroma: 8/12

Moderate hop aroma. Mostly notes of orange and a hint of lemon and tangerine. Moderate-low caramel malt sweetness with hints of toast. Very lower pear-like fruity esters. No diacetyl.

Appearance: 3/3

Deep gold in color. Slight off-white heat with tiny tight bubbles. Very clear. Good head retention.

25239356930_3bc25ac835_bFlavor:
14/20

Moderate orange, lemon, and tangerine hop flavor that gives the beer a boost of brightness. Moderate bitterness. Medium-low malt sweetness with low caramel and toasted bread notes. Very low fruity esters. Balance is slightly leaning toward the hops. Bitterness and tangerine fruitiness followings into the finish. Bitterness sticks around long into the finish, but is not unpleasant. No diacetyl.

Mouthfeel: 5/5

Medium body. Medium carbonation. No warmth. No creaminess. Low astringency.

Overall Impression:
7/10

Very tasty beer with solid citrus/american hop flavor. Very easy to drink IPA. The hop flavors and aroma are within style, but borderline on the upper end of the APA category. If the malt bill was a little smaller, I would consider this more of an APA. I would recommend increasing the hops near the end of boil and/or in the dry hop. Overall a very good beer.

TOTAL: 37/50

Comments: I really did enjoy this beer. I personally feel that this beer almost borders the line between styles. I’d consider the hop profile to be on the very low end of the spectrum for an IPA. I took a look at New Belgium’s website after writing my score sheet and saw they are using citra hopes (not a surprise based on the name) and tangerine peels. The tangerine notes add a bit of brightness I really enjoy. I would recommend to anyone who enjoys a solid hoppy beer.

Please share with fellow homebrewers...Tweet about this on TwitterShare on FacebookShare on Google+Pin on PinterestShare on LinkedInShare on Reddit

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.